Game 114: Tigers at White Sox

PREGAME: I’m going out to enjoy a lovely day on the beach. When I settle in tonight I’ll see if the Tigers as a collective team have anything left – like pride, or if they simply mail in the season. Zach Miner and Javier Vasquez. Last time this pitching match-up was a win. The bullpen should be well rested after they only had to get 1 out last night.

DET @ CHW, Thursday, August 7, 2008 Game Preview – Baseball-Reference.com

POSTGAME: Nothing to complain about in this one. Zach Miner was solid. The offense was good with the Carlos Guillen and Miguel Cabrera reaching base in each of their 5 respective plate appearances. Ryan Raburn made a bacon saving diving catch. Fernando Rodney was okay enough, and did K 2 without walking anyone. My man Bobby Seay was rocky, and Ramon Santiago had a 3 K game with an error. But otherwise good times. Now the Tigers just need to win 8 of their next 10 and we can all get excited again.

135 thoughts on “Game 114: Tigers at White Sox”

  1. FYI, billfer: indicating that the bullpen only had to get one out is not necessarily an indication that they are well-rested. If can take them 40-50 pitches and 2-3 pitchers to get 1 out.

    Anyhoo, enjoy the beach today, my sense is it will be good to get away. I’ll be at the game tonight, so now it’s your turn to buy me a beer.

  2. lost 6 straight now, 2 to division rivals…. it can’t really get much worse can it? I guess the tigers could find a way to make it worse

  3. HE GONE!!! Gaaaaaaaass!!

    and Jeremy, I think it’s pronounced o-vah.

    God how I hate those buffoons.

  4. “So, what was the upshot of all those June 7 – July 30 stats you posted yesterday?”

    Well, I’m glad you asked. During this time of blazing Tigers success – 31-16 – there were some notable contributors and non-contributors (in aggregate).

    The non-contributors, shackles on the legs of the team, were the 2 usual lineup suspects (do I even have to mention their names?), Todd Jones, Joel Zumaya, and Nate Robertson.

    Ranging from great to very good were Miguel Cabrera, Curtis Granderson, Justin Verlander, Armando Galarraga, Bobby Seay, Magglio Ordonez, Placido Polanco, Matt Joyce, and Marcus Thames. I’d say this is the honor roll of guys who have carried the Tigers to more than half – maybe much more than half – the team’s wins in 2008.

    Pudge’s numbers were amazing in terms of everything but actual run production.

  5. Well, let me tell you something…I don’t think I have ever seen somebody cover the Tigers like Billfer, and I mean EVER. He reminds me of a guy I used to play with…zzzzzzz

    Mark – my roommate and I were going to the game too, this morning his first words to me were, “you ready for the sweep?”, now only I am going.

  6. So I finally remembered one of my favorite Hawk gay-tangents. He was discussing the history of Comerica and how far back the fences originally were…from there he tied in the Juan Gonzalez franchise-saving non-signing, which he indicated had to do with him viewing the park as non-hitter friendly. Upon noting that immediately after his turning down of the 8 year, $140 million deal, the Tigers moved the fences in, Hawk referred to Gonzalez non-signing as “the biggest boner ever”. DJ was left dazed and confused, “uhhhh”. Hawk attempted to quickly recover by contextualizing the “boner” in question. It was fantastic.

  7. Andre, your story reveals DJ as the one with sexual identity issues. Any normal guy (normal = like us) would have come back with with the requisite boner joke. DJ was afraid to go there, with good reason.

  8. “DJ was afraid to go there, with good reason.”

    I don’t think I would want to explain to the FCC why I was discussing common sexual slang during a baseball game, either.

  9. Mark –

    I don’t suppose there are any bars near the stadium you’d recommend as Tig-friendly?

  10. “I don’t think I would want to explain to the FCC why I was discussing common sexual slang during a baseball game, either.”

    Ryan, I think they can get away with subtle double-entendre. Not that sports broadcasters are exactly famous for subtlety or the kind of intelligence that likes word play and wicked humor. Pat Hughes (Cubs) could do it. He’s so good it’s starting to rub off on Ron Santo. I actually think I’m liking both of them now. Gak.

  11. I don’t know of any good Tiger bars, Andre, sorry. As it is, I’ll get there right at game time. I figured it was only a matter of time until your roommate ended up the side of a milk carton. Enjoy the game with silence.

    and Sean, Bert Blyleven once dropped an F-bomb on air. That was subtle too.

  12. Someone on BYB posted this excerpt from the paper:

    “The Tigers have lost 19 games in which they led or were tied entering the seventh inning. If nine of those games had ended differently, the Tigers would be in first place in the American League Central. Instead, they entered Wednesday 7 1/2 games behind.”

    – Jon Paul Morosi, Detroit Free Press

    Good heavens.

  13. Sean C: “Pudge’s numbers were amazing in terms of everything but actual run production.”

    This is no surprise, since that trend (or meaningless statistical variance) of Pudge doing all his hitting on a clean slate lasted until he left (I refuse to look at his Yankee stats). And if the runners are on base in scoring position, it’s even worse.

    RISP: .237/.302/.382/.684

    AB per HR
    Bases empty: 36.6
    Men on: ***
    **unable to calculate until he hits one; 0 – 133 AB

    In other words, he basically turns into Inge, with less power.

    Unfortunately, he had an above-average % of AB with men on/RISP (43.5 / 24.0) although not as much as the unfortunate Renteria (46.8 / 27.1) who at least had 3 of his HR with men on (2 grand slams; AB per HR 58.7).

    Assuming the argument that things like “clutch hitting” etc are illusions, it would be interesting to move around guys in the batting order and use the split stats to get an idea what the ideal batting orders would have been in retrospect.

  14. Joel in Seattle:

    Just imagine how the Tigers would be doing if they were in the National League..

  15. “Assuming the argument that things like “clutch hitting” etc are illusions, it would be interesting to move around guys in the batting order and use the split stats to get an idea what the ideal batting orders would have been in retrospect.”

    Coleman, this will sound like a joke, but it’s not.

    If I had the time and the programming skill, I would take the results for every Tiger hitter PA, leaving them in their actual order, and attempt to find what the ideal alignment of them would have been to produce the most runs, which would include rearranging batting orders and even starts.

    OK, there is a joke part to it. I’m afraid I would end up with a lot of spare Renteria PA. I suppose I could use them up in the games Tigers pitching gave up 10+ runs, as long as I could assign them to all the Tigers just for those games.

  16. “and Sean, Bert Blyleven once dropped an F-bomb on air. That was subtle too.”

    Mark, I was thinking maybe just a tad more subtle than that.

  17. Coleman-

    I can’t tell if you believe they’d do better or worse, but since you seem to be offering a comparison, and they’re bad in the AL, I’ll assume you mean they’d do better in the NL.

    Problem with that is the whole giving Leyland more in-game decisions aspect that comes with the NL.

  18. ‘Just imagine how the Tigers would be doing if they were in the National League..”

    Why stop there? What if they were in the International League? They’d trail only Toledo. And if they were in the NFL, the NBA, or the NHL, they’d already have clinched a playoff spot.

  19. I’m saying that because of their interleague record. True, the AL teams seem to have a general advantage, presumably because the NL teams can’t dig up a decent DH when they play the away games. However:

    -um, yeah, DH is a huge advantage for DET. Not lately.

    -AL interleague record last 2 seasons: .562. DET: .750 So they exceed the typical AL team advantage.

    -Leyland factor. True, more managerial decisions. On the other hand: leaving the starter in too long? nope, just pinch-hit for him.

  20. Sean C: “Coleman, this will sound like a joke, but it’s not.”

    It could be worse, like when my jokes don’t sound like jokes.

    Actually though that was sort of the thing I was imagining; put Pudge in the lineup spot which had the most PA with bases empty (and of course all these stats change as you move guys around, Renteria in the spot most likely to have guys on 2nd but not 1st (he actually has been good with runners on when he can’t do that GIDP thing he likes so much), etc. It’s tricky though because it gets so multi-dimensional or exponential or what have you…it would be easy to find, say, the lineup spot where Inge’s stats say he would do best. But does moving the guy currently in that spot to another decrease his production by more than Inge’s increases, and what about the guy that used to be in the slot the displaced guy is now in? Oh my head…

  21. ‘It could be worse, like when my jokes don’t sound like jokes.”

    All your jokes sound like jokes to me, Coleman, but then again, anything you write has me poised for the joke that might not be there.

    I knew what you were saying about Detroit in the NL. I was being a smartass.

    Although it would be time-consuming, it wouldn’t be difficult to put every Tiger’s PA in sequence in a spreadsheet so you could then shift them around for optimum results. Let’s all quit our jobs. Surely someone here who is independently wealthy will offer us a grant, a stipendium, seed money to get us started.

  22. I think we could pull this off on the venture capitalists, because if it works, imagine how much you could charge for the info when teams are shelling out half a milliion per home run to old broken-down DHs. Plus it’s a win-win for the manager: if it works his team is better and his life is easier; if not–hey, don’t complain to me! Talk to the spreadsheet!

    The key thing is the naming of it…I’m thinking what would attract the most investment would be something moneyball sounding, without violating trademarks etc…hmm… The Moneybean sounds too much like a 90s .com bust…I’ll have to ponder this one…

  23. Good lineup today. The one that almost everybody has been calling for.

  24. It’s starting to bother me that Shane is still “temporarily” in Toledo, and by god if he isn’t called up when rosters expand someone is going to get an earful.

    It seems nobody plays the games I offered last night but I am not discouraged; perhaps they were “night games” and by the the time I posted the conceptuality of them most Billferistas were in that portion of their mental territory on which they have planted the flag they call “morning.”

    So I will make an attempt at something more daytime…

    So it is now the offseason. Jim Leyland has retired (although keeping his hotel suite, gratis, because of which, out of the entire year, there is not one day ok which it can be said that Mike Illitch is really happy?…the new manager is recently retired Jon Kitna. After pronouncing that the Tigers will win 100 games, his next big move is:_____

  25. Announcing the number on his jersey will be the Jesus Fish symbol? Dressing up like rapist Dmitri Young at a costume party?

  26. Get to finally watch a whole game tonight. Hopefully the Tigers can get it done. GO TiGeRs!!

  27. The DTW Dream Team:

    Granderson, CF
    Polanco, 2B
    Guillen, 3B
    Ordonez, DH
    Cabrera, 1B
    Joyce, RF
    Thames, LF
    Inge, C
    Santiago, SS

  28. cib– I’m right there with ya..probably the only way i’m gonna enjoy the game is with a few brewskis..lol Got some jaeger chillin in the event the game gets real bad. Shots for everyone!

  29. kay: these are excellent suggestions and you are so far winning the game; but spelling your name backwards is a threadbare disguise, and would it kill you to call me sometime?

    However I am thinking Mr Kitna needs a bench coach with a pocketful of experience, and another, and another, until he is dressing double-pants-wise with the pockets he needs. Because Mr Experience Nine-Pockets would impart to him
    the invaluable Irish proverb:

    It will be the breaking of your balls that you are feeling when you are after retiring the jersey number that all your team share common-like.

  30. So Marcus Thames is not an every day player, he’ll get “exposed” if you leave him in the lineup every day. Conventional thinking, no?

    I never bought it, and had never seen any evidence of this, so I spent some time researching his career, taking the number of plate appearances (PA) in each month of his career (leaving out his first month, June 2002 because that’s his only month in MLB that year, and played just a 7 games,and this month since it just started). I compared that against his OPS for each month.

    If he was not capable of being an every day player, his OPS would be lower for months that he gets more PA, i.e. negatively correlated. A zero correlation means no effect, and a positive correlation means more PA leads to higher OPS. I’ll be darned if the correlation didn’t work out to be +0.59.

    I’m not saying he’s going to be all-world if he bats leadoff every day, surely injuries and slumps that limit PA affect this analysis to some degree. But this whole idea that poor Marcus needs his rest just seems a little ridiculous. If he’s healthy, put him out there. He is country strong, after all!

    (Just had to share this in case anyone else cares. Below are the numbers I worked with from baseball-reference.com)

    Year Month PA OPS
    2003 July 23 0.716
    2003 August 50 0.55
    2003 Sept/Oct 11 0.382
    2004 June 17 0.176
    2004 July 69 1.141
    2004 August 51 0.477
    2004 Sept/Oct 47 1.02
    2005 April/March 29 0.476
    2005 May 57 0.865
    2005 June 8 0
    2005 Sept/Oct 24 0.701
    2006 April/March 42 0.989
    2006 May 57 1.113
    2006 June 104 0.985
    2006 July 73 0.683
    2006 August 51 0.966
    2006 Sept/Oct 63 0.595
    2007 April/March 36 0.765
    2007 May 41 0.813
    2007 June 42 0.653
    2007 July 46 0.977
    2007 August 74 0.66
    2007 Sept/Oct 45 0.86
    2008 April/March 39 0.653
    2008 May 43 0.911
    2008 June 80 1.139
    2008 July 78 0.721

  31. Amanda: good try Adam, but mixing up the letters on “an Adam” is a threadbare disguise. And would it kill you to call me sometime?

    At any rate it is a fine thing that you feel the gratitude, and the lucky fortune of your luck, to be watching your lone game entire, and that with the special shortstop that exceeds ham sandwich in his shortstoppery.

  32. Do not get too scared everybody, what Zach Miner threw in the first inning were called strikes and they are what pitchers are supposed to throw.

  33. haha Ole-Ma 🙂 The “C” and “N” really aren’t necessary but a nice disguise nonetheless
    And I’ll most enjoy watchin the game and reading the blogs as they happen. Could Cabrera have takin 2nd from that over throw at 1st base?

  34. “Could Cabrera have takin 2nd from that over throw at 1st base?”

    No.

  35. Rick G: I wish I were clever in a way that could understand your cleverness, or the secret of your name-code and what real name it conceals. And would it kill you to call me sometime?

    But if you are feeling kind or grateful for those days that were…please explain the conundrum of the proof that he who plays not every day is nonetheless the everyday player.. Surely it is in the interest of the manager to play the better players and yet the strongman playeth not…if the answer is something terrible by which you fear to overwhelm and trouble my mind, I thank you…but I would hope you yet have memory of my strength in the old times–do you really think he cannot handle the Truth of Thames who told your girlfriend her little dog, sadly, had been taken by a hawk and who listened so placidly to the earblasting thereupon?

  36. Actually it looks like Cabrera could have made 2nd, but he definitely would have bee thrown out going back to first to get his “friend on a 4-ft pole”

  37. How awesome is Cabrera? I really really hope that the several Cabrera-haters from the beginning of the season feel every bit as stupid now as we knew their statements to be at the time.

  38. hmmm i must be talking too much..pretty quiet around here. In light of the good pitching by Miner and the decent hits / runs we’re getting. Shhhhhh will be vewy quiewt *Elmer Fudd voice*

  39. Amanda, I think the quietness of DTW is due to the fact that the team’s playoff chances are looking dead.

    It’s a sad day in August when Detroit pro sports fans hold out more intest and hope for the Lions then the Tigers. I personaly don’t understand that. I predict that the Lions will be aweful- much worse than last year

  40. My lack of comments is due to the fact that a new episode of Burn Notice takes precedence over the 300th Tigers/White Sox game of the year 🙂

  41. I think everybody is holding thier breath or praying since the bullpen is in play. There’s one for Z. SHHHHHHH

  42. Here we go again . . . it’s got to be a mind thing now. Seay has to get two more outs without giving up a tying homer, it seems like a 50-50 proposition these days.

    EDIT: What horrible baserunning by the Chisox. Only one out to go in the inning. Thome’s actually slower than Miggy.

  43. I think Mike R said Thome appears to be swinging a red wood. Apparently, he runs like one too.

  44. well Thames should have been traded, they could have GOTTEN something decent for him.

    Ok, so here’s the new Tiger gameplan:

    woah, guys the next months worth of games are all against beatable teams:

    OAK at home for 3
    TOR at home for 3
    BAL at home for 3
    TEX on road for 3
    KC on road for 3
    CLE at home for 3
    KC at home for 3

    They better take advantage because the Twins and ChiSox have more difficult schedules.

    Twins:
    KC on road for 3
    NYY at home for 3
    SEA at home for 3
    OAK at home for 3
    They then start at 14 game road trip
    LAA on road for 4
    SEA on road for 3
    OAK on road for 4
    TOR on road for 3 (start of September)

    Hopefully, they can lose some (ok a lot) of these games.

    ChiSox:
    BOS at home for 4
    KC at home for 3
    OAK on road for 3
    SEA at home for 3
    TB at home for 3
    BAL on road for 3
    BOS on road for 3

    The ChiSox have had a more balanced schedule thus far but they still have to play some tough teams.

    Hopefully, the Tigers can start pitching. I still think it’s a matter of focus. They can still make up ground. They play the Twins 3 more time in Minny and the ChiSox 3 more times in Chicago.

    They have a big 4 game series with the Angels to start September at home. They need to prove they can be a championship contending team.

    I know I’m in the minority, but I still believe in this team. Their luck has been so bad this year I think, and I think they deserve for some good fortune.

  45. Just now checking in…appears I now tune in to just the exact moment that the wheels fall off. Sweet.

  46. Okay… not sure if Seay is hurt or not, but if he’s not, you absolutely leave in Seay. He needs one out. Let him work his way out of the jam.

    I give Rodney a 50%/50% chance getting out of this inning with the Tigers still in the lead.

  47. In 50 years of watching professional sportsI have never seen such psychopathic play affect an entire team with such predictability.

    Psychopathic.That’s the only way to describe it.

  48. Will another game this season ever end in an uneventful win?

    How many uneventful wins have the Tigers had this year, not counting games in which the Tigers scored 19 runs?

  49. Psychopathic.That’s the only way to describe it.

    The Tigers’ psychopath is in a Venezuelan prison.

  50. Boy oh boy. That’s the first time I’ve thought “Good thing we had a defensive replacement for Thames.”

  51. I dunno, Thames may have had that. In the way he kind of tumbles, loses his hat, contorts his body into strange positions. Nah, he woulda missed it…rolling to the wall, woohoo.

  52. That may be the first time we’ve seen the “intentionally walk Guillen to get to Maggs and a red-hot Cabrera” strategy this year?

  53. No win situation for Leyland.

    Keep Sombraro crookedo in…he blows it and people ask why not Z.

    Bring Z in …he blows it and people ask why not stick with Rodney?

    I would start with Rodney, with a quick hook.

  54. Well, Z ain’t coming in for sure today. But yes, I’d stick with Rodney. I’d rather not see Farnsworth face Quentin, Thome, or a pinch-hitting Dye.

    Anyways, looks like Maggs has made it a non-issue. Who knows with our ‘pen though.

  55. Agreed. Especially now that Maggs gave us some breathing room. Although, is there really such a thing as breathing room with this bullsh** pen?

  56. wow, Guillen hates Maggs, tries to be arrogant once again, tries to embarass Maggs. maggs would have none of that would he?

  57. What a change a great defensive play can make…Maggs, comes through, Joyce comes through…it is a relief!

  58. This may seem obvious, but I really like the approach that Joyce takes as a hitter. Especially for a rookie. Nice piece of hitting with that stroke to left.

  59. Here we go again. Hopefully a win here. Then a 10 game homestand. Tigers probably win 7 or 8 games just to get close in the race again to keep us all watching. I see it coming.

  60. I’m sure they’ll get just close enough to make me waste my money on MLB.tv for the last two months after I leave for school.

  61. 1. the Sox are obviously tired from beating on the Tigers the past three days
    2. if the Sox lose Leyland could get fired so they are throwing this game. Ozzie knows he can out coach the old man every day of the week. He wants Jim there
    3. The lead still isn’t big enough
    4. it AIN’T OVER UNTIL IT IS OVER

  62. great game all around for the Tigers. Need about 10 more of those in a row to make up for the crap we were served for the past few weeks though.

  63. The Tigers are good enough to win the division. They’re not half as good as the Angels, but DD doesn’t care about championships; he just wants butts in the seats and the illusion of “we can go all the way” attitude.

    The Tigers will win the division. Hello win streak. I think the next six weeks will be fun.

  64. Palmcroft is either actually Chief Monday, or has gotten into the Oxycontin and beer again.

  65. Does anyone know where Palmcroft and Chief Monday purchase their amazing koolaid? Personally, I think it would go great with a ham sandwich. In fact, I’m going to go as far as saying that drinking said koolaid while consuming the ham sandwich is the only way to truely enjoy the sandwich.

  66. So I’m back from the game last night. Big game for me, first time they’ve won a game I went to.

    It was weird, our entire row was Detroit fans, except my roommate…who by the way jinxed himself by saying “ready for the sweep” last morning. I was sitting next to some seven year old kid and, at one point, Joyce let an out get past him for a ground rule double, I made a comment about him sucking as a outfielder and the kid got on my case.

    It was odd having to defend myself against a seven year old…especially since i was a little loaded at that point and had to hold back on my urge to make fun of him and point out he was wearing a Pudge jersey.

    I think i managed a coherent argument about Joyce being a decent bat, but rather having him DH instead of Maggs. When Joyce got the last RBI, the kid taunted me…

    I took it pretty well i think, especially when you consider the last time i went to a game i made fun of a Sox-kid who didn’t spell his sign right…I don’t know what it is about that ballpark that turns me into a child-hating a-hole.

  67. Do you really think Maggs is a better outfielder than Joyce? I agree he may not have played that ball very well (the ground rule double), but I suspect he’s probably the Tigers’ second best outfielder at the moment.

    This probably doesn’t mean a whole lot, but he was voted the Best Defensive Outfielder in the Eastern League last year. Matt Walbeck (his manager at the time) said the only reason he wasn’t sent down when he struggled so badly in April and May last year was his defense was so good.

  68. Matt Walbeck is now the third base coach here for the Rangers. And a bad one at that. He almost got David Murphy and Pudge killed on the same play.

  69. Matt-

    Mostly it was just a funny story of my drunk-@ss defending a comment to a zealous kid.

    However, I’m wondering if you watched the game (can’t remember, I think it was the first game of the series) where in extra innings, bottom of the inning with the W. Sox at bat, bases loaded and less than two outs…Joyce playing DEEP in LF. While the whole team is freaking out, players, coaches, everyone is telling him to come in…and Joyce sits there like, “I got this”.

    Maybe that situation was out of the ordinary and doesn’t reflect his overall ability (in general I’m basing my judgement on a small sample size), but I’ve seen him make some pretty off target throws as well.

  70. Drink the kool-aid.
    It is better than the pre-DD & JL years.

    I prefer to think of those one run losses and extra innings losses as good games anyway.

  71. Going way back on the thread here, but I thought Rick G’s post about Marcus was really interesting. I was always skeptical about the argument that he’d be bad as an everyday player, but had nothing but my own instincts to base that on. Rick seems to have disproved the theory somewhat. I actually wonder if Marcus’ recent slump might have a lot to do with Leyland waffling and wavering on what his true role is going to be. A while back, he was going to be the everyday left fielder. That was followed by a rotation of leftfield starters that never seemed to have much rhyme or reason. Maybe if Leyland ever followed through with any of his pronouncements, he’d get better production for his players.

  72. “but I thought Rick G’s post about Marcus was really interesting.”

    I did, too. Good work, Rick, and thanks.

  73. Going strictly by those numbers, you can make the argument that Marcus Thames is a streaky hitter. I’m not in favor of playing ‘streaky’ hitters every day, simply because the cold spells absolutely kill you. A couple of examples, using Rick’s stats from above (I’m going to discount anything prior to 2006):

    Year Month PA OPS
    2006 June 104 0.985
    2006 July 73 0.683
    losing 300 points of OPS is unacceptable

    2006 August 51 0.966
    2006 Sept/Oct 63 0.595
    again, losing 370 points of OPS isn’t cutting it

    2007 May 41 0.813
    2007 June 42 0.653
    starting to see a trend? (P.S. an 813 OPS ain’t that great to begin with for a corner OF)

    2007 July 46 0.977
    2007 August 74 0.66
    OK I’m going to stop now

    An added note – I don’t think a corner OF with a career .304 OBP in over 1300 PA is screaming “play me every day”.

  74. So, assume that JV, Bondo and Willis are in the starting rotation next year. I know Willis is a stretch, but he’s getting paid a lot of money, he’ll at least be given a chance. You can also say that the Tigers try hard to sign a #1 or #2 starter off the FA market. The bottom line is, you have 3 slots full.

    Who rounds out the rotation? I’d favor Battlestar and Zach Miner, letting Nate work out of the bullpen and spot start (or included in a trade for another important piece). While he’s been largely pilloried around here, I’d imagine such a move would be controversial. What do you guys think?

  75. Your 2009 Tigers starting rotation: Verlander-Bonderman-Willis-Galarraga-Sabathia

    OK that one’s probably just a pipe dream. Replace fatty with Robertson and that’s probably what it actually will be. Though Miner has proven capable of starting, I have to think with the money owed to Robertson that he’d get the nod. I have to think that Bonderman should have a bounce back season, having (hopefully) fixed what has been causing him the elbow troubles. Really when he’s been 100% healthy he’s an excellent #3 starter (a #2 if you discount the first inning – had to throw that tried and true criticism in there…)

  76. The FA starter that I’m really looking at is Ben Sheets. He’s a great pitcher, and I think he’s someone the Tigers would be willing to sign.

  77. So far I’m with you Joel. Battlestar has been pretty lucky, but appears to be at least a competent starter. He could act as a swingman if we are able to land another starter, too Miner is clearly more comfortable in the rotation and has strung together a nice couple starts. I think he deserves a shot as the #5 next year if he keeps this up.

    I don’t know if they try to sign a big FA starter. Sabathia is obviously the prize, but the payroll is pretty high and the Yankees, Dodgers, Mets, Cubs?, etc. will throw a ton of money at him. Sheets has too much injury history. Also, a guy like Porcello may be ready to contribute by midseason.

    So what happens to Nate? Given his perfomance this year, I’d love to see him shipped out of town, but I doubt that will happen. Maybe he gets traded, but his value just isn’t that high, so DD would be selling low. Best guess is he ends up in the rotation next year and there’s no FA signing, except for the bullpen.

  78. I don’t know if they try to sign a big FA starter. Sabathia is obviously the prize, but the payroll is pretty high

    Not as high as it looks on the surface. The ’08 payroll was a whopping $137 million (3rd in baseball). Subract the following: $13 million (Pudge), $8 million (Rogers), $7 million (Jones), $10 million (Renteria) and you’re down to right around $100 million. Of course some guys have escelators in their contracts so they’ll be making more next year and there will be holes to plug, but I think they could free up enough payroll to make a push for a Sabathia. And after ’09 Sheffield’s contract is gone as well. I’m no economist, but I think they should give it a shot. Sheets is too risky health-wise.

  79. I forgot to add if they can ditch Robertson and his $4 million, that probably would help too.

  80. Sheets is a risk health-wise, but if they could get a nice contract laid out (Magglio?), I think it would be a good investmend. Sabathia would be amazing of course, but every time I imagine the Sabathia of the future, he’s in pinstripes. Or somewhere in the northeast, at least. Maybe Illitch and DD have the balls to get him, who knows.

  81. First, oxycontin and beer only enhance my enthusiasm. Masked by losing, the Tigers started to get things in order in Chicago. Chuckie is, frankly, coaching his *ss off. Good times ‘a comin.

    My worry about Galarraga in the future is his heavy reliance on the slider. I carefully watched his near perfecto a few weeks ago, it seemed like every other pitch was a slider. To my mind, he is not a projectible member of a future Tigers staff with such a lopsided mix. His elbow ligament will not take it.

  82. That’s what I use to think about Jurrjens. I didn’t think his elbow could take it and though he’d never be a reliable starter. Tiger’s management agreed. So off he went.

  83. One out-of-the-box idea would be to flip Galarraga for someone in the offseason if he can keep up with his pace. I surmise his trade value would never be higher than it is right now. I doubt they’d be able get the haul they got for Jurrjens/Hernandez (coughsarcasmcough), but they might be able to land something decent.

  84. Chris in D: I’ll agree that Marcus has been steaky in the past. But I wonder if some of that has to do with him never knowing when his next at bat is coming. The positive correlation Rick showed between his PAs and OPS seems to indicate that he might be more productive overall if he saw more regular at bats. This season, we saw him go through an amazing hot streak, followed by the manager proclaiming him the starter in left. That was followed by more of the same platooning with Joyce, Thomas, etc. Not to mention being lifted for defense, often as early as the seventh inning (more lost PAs). I have to think that messes with you as a hitter.

  85. Ryan: What you say may be true. But after three or four years or whatever of not getting regular AB, you’d think he might have adjusted to it by now. Not to say that I don’t like Marcus (I do), but some guys are starters and some guys are bench players – I think he’s the latter. That’s not necessarily bad. I think it’s quite a luxury to have power like that coming off of your bench.

  86. Chief:

    I thought Jurrjens was one of the smartest young pitchers I’d seen in years. He really knew how to work through an order, how to adjust while on the mound, terrific location and movement. I didn’t see what you did, that is, an overreliance on one pitch.

    If there’s such a thing as a “pitchers IQ,” Jair had it. He threw a two-hitter last year that I thought was the finest game I’d seen pitched in ages.

    I think Mussina and Maddux are the smartest pitchers going today, and Jair has the makeup to join them. I hated to see him go.

  87. The Louisville Slugger Company loved Jurrjens. He broke more bats per outing than any Tigers pitcher in recent memory.

  88. In 2007, Jurrjens was terrible his last 2 starts for the Tigers though. After last season, even Bazardo looked better than Jurrjens.

Comments are closed.