Using retrosheet play-by-play to judge historical defense. From 56-86 Whitaker was the best defensive 2nd baseman using this method – and that was only a fraction of his career. Plus Al Kaline was tops in right field.
Baseball Reference is doing a free trial of the Play Index. PI is wonderful and I highly, highly recommend it and use it on a daily basis during the season. You can use this free trial to try and win a free year subscription.
Dan Fox looks at those individuals who are a good candidate for a shiift (like for Big Papi, Hafner, Thome, etc). Curtis shows up on the list, but his speed and bunting threat would probably be a deterrent.